edited by Iona & Peter Opie, illustrated by Maurice Sendak. (1992) Published by Candlewick Press. 160 pages.
There’s nothing in this book of taunts, chants and schoolyard riddles that will make you pause very long and ponder the meaning of life, Nor do these poems have the sometimes fantastical scope that you’ll get from a more “legitimate” book of nursery rhymes. But this book is a lot of fun because the editors have no compunction about filling their book with the silliness and capriciousness of true childhood. And Maurice Sendak’s illustrations give you a sense that spirit of this book, if not some of the rhymes themselves, reaches back beyond all the finery of the renaissance to the gritty and grubby world of the dark ages.
Showing posts with label Book Review: English language: Children's Book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book Review: English language: Children's Book. Show all posts
The Lotus Caves
by John Christopher. (1968) Published by Collier Books. 215 pages.
Reviewed 24 November 2007
A little ways into “Lotus Caves” the first big mistake comes up: the main character, a child named Marty, has a friend over and they listen to some music—on tape. In this science fiction story set in a colony on the moon in the year 2068, the presence of audiotape is an obvious, if forgivable, flaw. It’s also a flaw that betrays a lot about the man who made it.
The lunar colony of “Lotus Caves” is characterized by scarcity. All resources must be shepherded, messes and waste are forbidden. Christopher isn’t interested in extolling the state of tomorrow’s technology, but in underlining its disappointments; in the schools of the lunar colony (informally called “The Bubble”) the students are able to enter into holographic reconstructions of past eras—the Roman Empire, for instance—but the technology to simulate tastes and smells has been forbidden, for fear that it will make children distressed over all they miss out on by not being raised on the world.
I first got to know John Christopher in elementary school, where I read his “White Mountains” trilogy and was captivated by it. John Christopher is a children’s writer who is quite concerned about the state of childhood in the modern world. In “White Mountains” we have a world colonized by aliens who implant hardware into the brains of adults in order to make it impossible to rebel or even think disobedient thoughts. In “Lotus Caves” it’s all about a sort of squalor of the senses and the soul, a legislated dispiritedness and pessimism. I imagine that the soul stifling culture of the Bubble is based on the rationing of goods in England after the Second World War.
What’s really interesting to me is the nature of the main characters in this book. Marty and his friend Steve seem to be remarkably thoughtful children. Even though the whole plot is driven by their disobedience (they take a lunar crawler out beyond the bounds of radio transmission) they don’t seem at all like “problem children.” There’s no roughhousing or mouthing off or restlessness. But the characters are not miniature adults. This is the sort of child that I was growing up . . . or rather, I had the distinct potential to be this sort of child. I engaged in long thoughtful spells and was quite curious about books, even though my learning difficulty made it difficult to read them. I think during the 1980s American culture was just starting to move away from encouraging these sorts of character traits in children, maybe because thoughtful children are less likely to push their parents to buy things; I don’t know. What I do know is that John Christopher’s vision of childhood is something important that we shouldn’t lose track of.
The storyline of “The Lotus Caves” shouldn’t be too unfamiliar to anyone who watched the old Star Trek series. While exploring the moon, the two children stumble across a cave inhabited by an advanced life form, a massive plant that fills the whole cave in the form of mushrooms, vines, trees that produce organ music, grassy meadows and luminescent moss. Because the organism doesn’t want the human colonists to find out about its existence, it insists on keeping the children locked up inside its domain. If offers to keep them entertained and feeds them fruit that levels their personality and quells their desire for escape. In order to succeed, the characters have to find a way to overcome their complacency and build their fighting spirit. In the end, their escape from the caves is pretty easy. The plant doesn’t put up much of a fight; indeed, it’s much easier for the boys to liberate themselves from the forbidden caves than it was for them to get away from their human settlement on the other side of the moon.
The friendship between Steve and Marty is the weakest part of the book. We're told that Steve is the domineering one, and that Marty has to “gain ascendancy” over him in order to pull off the escape from the caves. But Steve doesn’t seem to have much personality of his own, and there’s definitely a coda in their relationship missing from the end of the book.
But what’s good about this book is that it does such a great job at raising the frightening specter of a lifeless, overly controlled childhood, a childhood where all sense of joy and abandonment has been legislated away. There are lots of kids who are in no danger of this, but for some kids the biggest danger is to shy away into a life of obedient introversion. You can’t just deny that kind of personality; there are those of us that are contemplative by nature, who spend a lot of their lives in our heads. But there’s a crisis point where an introspective person has to decide whether or not to succumb fully to the undertow of isolation, or to spend a lifetime fighting the current and making efforts to get out and participate in life. This crisis is very real to those of us who face it; what’s rare about Christopher’s work is how well he brings it to life.
Reviewed 24 November 2007
A little ways into “Lotus Caves” the first big mistake comes up: the main character, a child named Marty, has a friend over and they listen to some music—on tape. In this science fiction story set in a colony on the moon in the year 2068, the presence of audiotape is an obvious, if forgivable, flaw. It’s also a flaw that betrays a lot about the man who made it.
The lunar colony of “Lotus Caves” is characterized by scarcity. All resources must be shepherded, messes and waste are forbidden. Christopher isn’t interested in extolling the state of tomorrow’s technology, but in underlining its disappointments; in the schools of the lunar colony (informally called “The Bubble”) the students are able to enter into holographic reconstructions of past eras—the Roman Empire, for instance—but the technology to simulate tastes and smells has been forbidden, for fear that it will make children distressed over all they miss out on by not being raised on the world.
I first got to know John Christopher in elementary school, where I read his “White Mountains” trilogy and was captivated by it. John Christopher is a children’s writer who is quite concerned about the state of childhood in the modern world. In “White Mountains” we have a world colonized by aliens who implant hardware into the brains of adults in order to make it impossible to rebel or even think disobedient thoughts. In “Lotus Caves” it’s all about a sort of squalor of the senses and the soul, a legislated dispiritedness and pessimism. I imagine that the soul stifling culture of the Bubble is based on the rationing of goods in England after the Second World War.
What’s really interesting to me is the nature of the main characters in this book. Marty and his friend Steve seem to be remarkably thoughtful children. Even though the whole plot is driven by their disobedience (they take a lunar crawler out beyond the bounds of radio transmission) they don’t seem at all like “problem children.” There’s no roughhousing or mouthing off or restlessness. But the characters are not miniature adults. This is the sort of child that I was growing up . . . or rather, I had the distinct potential to be this sort of child. I engaged in long thoughtful spells and was quite curious about books, even though my learning difficulty made it difficult to read them. I think during the 1980s American culture was just starting to move away from encouraging these sorts of character traits in children, maybe because thoughtful children are less likely to push their parents to buy things; I don’t know. What I do know is that John Christopher’s vision of childhood is something important that we shouldn’t lose track of.
The storyline of “The Lotus Caves” shouldn’t be too unfamiliar to anyone who watched the old Star Trek series. While exploring the moon, the two children stumble across a cave inhabited by an advanced life form, a massive plant that fills the whole cave in the form of mushrooms, vines, trees that produce organ music, grassy meadows and luminescent moss. Because the organism doesn’t want the human colonists to find out about its existence, it insists on keeping the children locked up inside its domain. If offers to keep them entertained and feeds them fruit that levels their personality and quells their desire for escape. In order to succeed, the characters have to find a way to overcome their complacency and build their fighting spirit. In the end, their escape from the caves is pretty easy. The plant doesn’t put up much of a fight; indeed, it’s much easier for the boys to liberate themselves from the forbidden caves than it was for them to get away from their human settlement on the other side of the moon.
The friendship between Steve and Marty is the weakest part of the book. We're told that Steve is the domineering one, and that Marty has to “gain ascendancy” over him in order to pull off the escape from the caves. But Steve doesn’t seem to have much personality of his own, and there’s definitely a coda in their relationship missing from the end of the book.
But what’s good about this book is that it does such a great job at raising the frightening specter of a lifeless, overly controlled childhood, a childhood where all sense of joy and abandonment has been legislated away. There are lots of kids who are in no danger of this, but for some kids the biggest danger is to shy away into a life of obedient introversion. You can’t just deny that kind of personality; there are those of us that are contemplative by nature, who spend a lot of their lives in our heads. But there’s a crisis point where an introspective person has to decide whether or not to succumb fully to the undertow of isolation, or to spend a lifetime fighting the current and making efforts to get out and participate in life. This crisis is very real to those of us who face it; what’s rare about Christopher’s work is how well he brings it to life.
The Invention of Hugo Cabret
by Brian Selznick. 2007. Published by Scholastic Press. 534 pages.
Reviewed 20 October 2007
In my lifetime, an interesting cultural switcheroo has taken place. What happens backstage is much more interesting to us now than what happens onstage; practically every DVD comes with a compilation of interviews and outtakes detailing the process of how the film was made. Political campaign coverage focuses on fundraising and campaign logistics. It’s no longer necessary for us to suspend our disbelief; it’s not so important now that we succumb to illusions as that we are curious about how the illusion is accomplished. There’s the danger here that all this will result in a gradual death of the faculty of imagination. The wonder of tales and legends will be deflated and replaced merely with a bland, utilitarian interest in plain facts. But there’s also the hope that as viewers and readers get more interested in the processes of creativity, a new sort of legend will begin springing up, one which brings creators and audiences closer together.
“The Invention of Hugo Cabret” is a perfect example. The author’s love of silent movies is captured in the sumptuous pencil, charcoal and chalk drawings as well as in the way that the illustration and text are interspersed. At the core of this novel is a good deal of sound research into the history of the first years of cinema, the movies of Harold Lloyd, Charlie Chaplin, the Lumire Brothers and Georges Méliés. And around this core is built a narrative that incorporates all the pathos and simplicity of these old classics. The story is about an orphan boy, Hugo Cabret, who steals the inner workings from windup toys in order to rebuild an old clockwork automaton. Along the way, Hugo meets the orphaned girl Isabelle; her stepfather forbids her visiting movie houses, but still she’s fallen in love with the medium, and sneaks Hugo in to see a matinee showing. In this sequence, the narration gives way to the image of a set of heavy, tasseled curtains pulling aside to reveal an empty screen. Then we see the light of the projector come on and finally, the image of Hugo’s face, lips parted, eyes widening, the contours of his cheekbones and forehead highlighted by the reflected glow of the screen.
In this scene and in the whole book, you can almost feel the flicker of an old movie projector as it churns out the story, reel after reel after reel.
Reviewed 20 October 2007
In my lifetime, an interesting cultural switcheroo has taken place. What happens backstage is much more interesting to us now than what happens onstage; practically every DVD comes with a compilation of interviews and outtakes detailing the process of how the film was made. Political campaign coverage focuses on fundraising and campaign logistics. It’s no longer necessary for us to suspend our disbelief; it’s not so important now that we succumb to illusions as that we are curious about how the illusion is accomplished. There’s the danger here that all this will result in a gradual death of the faculty of imagination. The wonder of tales and legends will be deflated and replaced merely with a bland, utilitarian interest in plain facts. But there’s also the hope that as viewers and readers get more interested in the processes of creativity, a new sort of legend will begin springing up, one which brings creators and audiences closer together.
“The Invention of Hugo Cabret” is a perfect example. The author’s love of silent movies is captured in the sumptuous pencil, charcoal and chalk drawings as well as in the way that the illustration and text are interspersed. At the core of this novel is a good deal of sound research into the history of the first years of cinema, the movies of Harold Lloyd, Charlie Chaplin, the Lumire Brothers and Georges Méliés. And around this core is built a narrative that incorporates all the pathos and simplicity of these old classics. The story is about an orphan boy, Hugo Cabret, who steals the inner workings from windup toys in order to rebuild an old clockwork automaton. Along the way, Hugo meets the orphaned girl Isabelle; her stepfather forbids her visiting movie houses, but still she’s fallen in love with the medium, and sneaks Hugo in to see a matinee showing. In this sequence, the narration gives way to the image of a set of heavy, tasseled curtains pulling aside to reveal an empty screen. Then we see the light of the projector come on and finally, the image of Hugo’s face, lips parted, eyes widening, the contours of his cheekbones and forehead highlighted by the reflected glow of the screen.
In this scene and in the whole book, you can almost feel the flicker of an old movie projector as it churns out the story, reel after reel after reel.
Dear Mili
(1988) by Wilhelm Grimm. Translated by Ralph Manheim. Illustrated by Maurice Sendak. Michael di Capua Books. (21 March 2007).
28 March 2007
The text of this book is from a recently discovered manuscript by Wilhelm Grimm. The dust-jacket blurbs make it out to be a previously undiscovered fairy tale to complement “Cinderella,” “Hansel and Gretel,” and “Red Riding Hood.” But actually, the story here is much closer to religious allegory than what you’d expect to find in a normal Grimm Brothers’ fairy tale—and this is an excellent vehicle for Maurice Sendak, whose talent is to mix images from the worlds of adulthood and childhood and to invite readers from each side of the age divide to look at the details from their counterparts’ perspective, details they normally would filter out. This is a story of the enduring love of a mother for her lost child. Images of trees and flowers, of spreading roots and ruined chapels and crumbling tombstones fill every page and give us a sense of the power time has both to deepen our sorrows, and to bring about a sea change into ripeness and redemption.
28 March 2007
The text of this book is from a recently discovered manuscript by Wilhelm Grimm. The dust-jacket blurbs make it out to be a previously undiscovered fairy tale to complement “Cinderella,” “Hansel and Gretel,” and “Red Riding Hood.” But actually, the story here is much closer to religious allegory than what you’d expect to find in a normal Grimm Brothers’ fairy tale—and this is an excellent vehicle for Maurice Sendak, whose talent is to mix images from the worlds of adulthood and childhood and to invite readers from each side of the age divide to look at the details from their counterparts’ perspective, details they normally would filter out. This is a story of the enduring love of a mother for her lost child. Images of trees and flowers, of spreading roots and ruined chapels and crumbling tombstones fill every page and give us a sense of the power time has both to deepen our sorrows, and to bring about a sea change into ripeness and redemption.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
